ABSTRACT

In the present study pulp and paper industry effluent was treated with the help of aluminum electrode using electrocoagulation (EC) process with feasible sludge management. The influences of pH, time, current density and electrolytes dose were investigated and optimum conditions were established to reduce the maximum amount of Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) and color. At optimum conditions 70% of COD and 98% of color were removed. Additionally, the behavior of electrolytes (NaCl and Na₂SO₄) was determined; it has shown that Na₂SO₄ results in the generation of less secondary pollutants than that NaCl and thereby could be used as better replacement in paper industries for electrocoagulation mediated treatment of wastewater. The residual amount of operational parameters in EC treated water was compared to the World Health Organization (WHO) and Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) of India. It was found to be safe for utilization in irrigation. Furthermore, sludge produced during the EC process has been analyzed for physicochemical characteristics. To understand the physical and elemental phases of sludge, the analytical technique such as field emission electron microscope coupled with energy dispersive spectroscopy has been used to find out the possible management alternative.

Keywords:

Pulp and Paper Wastewater, Electrocoagulation, Reuse, Irrigation, Sustainable Sludge Management

1. Introduction

The production of paper by pulp and paper industries requires a tremendous volume of fresh water (10 - 110 m³ per tonne) subsequently generating the high volume of effluent therefore considered to be one of the most polluting industries [1]. This industry generates wastewater which has a large amount of total solids (TS), color, numerous recalcitrant compounds and increased chemical oxygen demand (COD) [2]. More than 250 chemicals compounds have been acknowledged in effluents generated at different stages of papermaking including phenols and Chlorophenols compounds, resin and fatty acid, lignin and its derivatives [3] [4] [5]. If this effluent is directly discharged into the environment it will lead to significant environmental damage such as loss of environmental aesthetics, the extensive negative effect on aquatic animals, likewise seriously affecting the terrestrial ecosystem [6] [7] [8] [9]. The pulp and paper industry wastewater has been listed in the “red category” by the Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change (MOEFCC), India CPCB, India which indicates the severity of associated pollution risk [10]. Thus, there is an urgent need of the suitable treatment for wastewater generated by pulp and paper industry. The Indian paper industries adopted pre, primary and secondary treatment facility to treat the wastewater, but they have failed to achieve complete degradation of recalcitrant compounds and attain the satisfactory level of treatment [5] [6]. There are various technologies like, aerobic and anaerobic, adsorption, advanced oxidation, membrane separation process and chemical coagulation which can be used for the removal of refractory chemicals [11] - [16]. However, these methods have their own limitations such as high cost, high chemical consumption, longer retention time, and chances of secondary pollution. Additionally, biochemical methods cannot be applied to treat paper industry wastewater due to the limitation of lower biodegradability [17] [18]. Recently, Electrocoagulation (EC) method attracted the researcher’s attention as an alternative with some attractive factors which make EC process one of the most important technologies for treating the wastewater. EC uses simple equipment with ease of automation while no or very few chemicals are required to be added to this process [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]. Additionally, O₂ and H₂ bubbles are formed during the process which improves the separation efficiency by electro-flotation and it can handle a wide variety of pollutants [24] [25] [26]. In EC method three main stages are involved 1) Electrolytic reaction at anode and cathode surfaces 2) Formation of coagulant in solution 3) Suspended pollutant matter gets adsorbed on coagulant and gets removed by settling and flotation process. In EC, generally anode releases positive metal hydroxide ions at desired pH [21] [22] [27]. In this study aluminum was used as the electrode and the mechanism of reaction during the EC process for both anode and cathode are represented below:

Anode: $\text{Al}\to {\text{Al}}^{3+}+3{\text{e}}^{-}$ (1)

Cathode: $3{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}+3{\text{e}}^{-}\to \frac{3}{2}{\text{H}}_2+3{\text{OH}}^{-}$ (2)

Under high pH condition, H₂ produced OH ions at cathode [22].

$2\text{Al}+6{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}+2{\text{OH}}^{-}\to 2\text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_4^{-}+3{\text{H}}_2$ (3)

In EC, Al³⁺ and OH⁻ ions were generated at electrode and they react to form various monomeric species such as Al(OH)²⁺, $\text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_4^{+}$ , ${\text{Al}}_{\text{2}}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_2^{4+}$ , $\text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_4^{-}$ and polymeric species such as ${\text{Al}}_{\text{6}}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{15}^{3+}$ , ${\text{Al}}_7{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{17}^{4+}$ , ${\text{Al}}_8{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{20}^{4+}$ , ${\text{Al}}_{\text{13}}{\text{O}}_{\text{4}}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{24}^{7+}$ , ${\text{Al}}_{\text{13}}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{34}^{5+}$ which finally transformed into Al(OH)_3(s) according to complex precipitation kinetics [21] [28] [29].

${\text{Al}}^{3+}+3{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}\to \text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_{3\left(\text{s}\right)}+3{\text{H}}^{+}$ (4)

These Al(OH)_3(s) flocs produced during the treatment, have the larger surface area, which strengthen the removal of pollutants from wastewater through adsorption or precipitation. Al(OH)_3(s) have the neutral characteristic which function as a coagulating agent in the reaction vessel for the suspended and contaminated particle. Finally, these flocs are separated from the treated wastewater without any difficulty by sedimentation or H₂ floatation [22] [28]. In recent years, the approach of EC treatment process has been extensively used for the treatment of various types of effluent including dye containing effluent [21] , lignin and phenol [29] , Oil refinery wastewater [30] , textile effluent [22] , pharmaceutical industry effluent [20] , recalcitrant and dissolved organic matter from paper industry effluent [12]. The previous literature has widely discussed the operating parameters and associated physical and chemical reaction to complete the process but, physicochemical characterization of sludge and management of sludge has been studied poorly. The production of sludge is an integral part of EC process and considered as a waste material, therefore pulp and paper mills in India get rid of this sludge by landfilling practices [31]. However, such practices of land filling are associated with potential risk of polluting the soil, water table and entire ecosystem. From the environmental perspective, the disposal of sludge becomes a challenging task which needs immediate sustainable management. As per our best knowledge, there have been studies which have categorically focused on the settling characteristics and sludge volume index of electrocoagulation sludge, whereas there has been a consistent lack of research efforts in the direction of physicochemical characteristics, and elemental analysis of EC sludge investigation [32] [33] [34]. Similarly, very few studies have been conducted on the removal of biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), chemical COD, and total organic carbon (TOC) evaluation of wastewater. The studies related to sludge management and treated water reused also less reported. The objectives of the present study were to develop the optimum conditions for the treatment of pulp and paper industry wastewater and sludge management. To investigate the optimum conditions of treatment, COD and color were taken into consideration and the resulting optimum conditions were utilized to determine the BOD, TOC, total dissolved solids (TDS) and conductivity of wastewater to find out the option to reuse EC treated water in irrigation and sludge for further application.

2. Materials and Methods

2.1. Wastewater Sample Collection and Characterization

The effluent sample was procured from the nearby paper industry after the primary treatment. The industry used OCEpHH bleaching sequence for the production of pulp and paper. Collected sample was stored below 4˚C in the laboratory for further investigation. General characteristics of collected effluent are presented in Table 1. The evaluation of the study was performed on the basis of reduction in COD and color at the various pH, current density, time, and dose of electrolytes. Further, at the optimum conditions, the samples were analyzed using different environmental parameters such as pH, BOD₃, COD TOC, color, conductivity, TDS and sludge characterization as per standard methods [35]. The treatment efficiency was evaluated in terms of COD and color reduction percentage using the following equation:-

$\text{Treatment efficiency}\left(\%\right)=\frac{I_0-F_t}{I_0}\times 100$ (5)

where, I₀ = Initial value, F_t = Final value at time t.

2.2. Sludge Characterization

The EC process completed within 30 min and after the completion of every run, a viscous mixture of semi liquid and solid was settled at the bottom while scum content was moved upwards at the top of reaction vessel. The sludge was collected after applying filter process, both sludge and scum were dried for three to four days at room temperature followed by oven drying in at 105˚C until constant weight was obtained (Popular Model No. HAC405) and finally crushed in mortar pestle for further used. Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscope (FESSEM, MIRA3 TESCAN) coupled with energy dispersive X-ray spectrometry (AMETEK EDAX) was used to determine morphological characteristics and elemental analysis of sludge respectively.

2.3. Electrocoagulation Unit

The schematic diagram of batch scale laboratory experimental setup is shown in Figure 1. The EC experiment and electrodes configuration details are given in Table 2. The experimental unit was stirred with a magnetic stirrer at 100 rpm

for the uniform mixing of wastewater. Uniform and the continuous power supply are mandatory to achieve satisfactory result during wastewater treatment. India having 250 - 300 clear and sunny days in a year hence considered as a tropical country. So, it has huge solar energy potential which can be easily utilized as a source of power [36]. Moreover, Government of India promoting solar energy by initiating many schemes and subsidized the programme such as National Solar Mission and several central financial assistance schemes and encourages the public to adopt green and clean energy approach. Photovoltaic (PV) is a most popular source of renewable energy, was used as a direct power source and connected to direct power supply because in EC method direct current (DC) is utilized [37]. Application of PV as a power source successfully applied in electrochemical method to treat various types of water and wastewater [38] [39] [40] [41]. It reduced the load and expenses of electricity, cost of equipment for converting the alternate current into direct current. Low maintenance cost, long life, and nonpolluting nature are positive factors of PV which make it a promising and safe alternative for wastewater treatment [42].

3. Results and Discussion

3.1. Parameters Optimization

Paper mill wastewater consists of the heavy organic load in terms of COD and color. The study was carried out for the optimization of different variables i.e. pH (5.0 - 9.0), time (10 - 50 min), current density (5.04 - 25.20 mA/cm⁻²) and electrolyte dose (0.5 - 2.0 g/L). All these parameters were determined on the basis of maximum COD and color removal.

3.2. Effect of pH

The pH is one of the major parameters to determine the performance of the EC process [43] [44] [45]. The impact of pH was investigated for the elimination of COD and color; all other parameters were kept constant during this study. Reduction percentage of color and COD showed positive relation till the pH range of 5 to 7. The highest COD (23%) and color (42%) removal was observed at pH 7 (Figure 2). As the pH goes higher from neutral pH 7, the reduction rate

of COD and color started declining and lowest color (35%) and COD removal (12%) was observed at pH 9 (Figure 2). The higher COD and color removal at pH 7 is observed to be due to the formation of aluminum hydroxide Al(OH)₃ (Reaction 7). Al(OH)₃ has a larger surface area and is amphoteric in nature which enhances the coagulation process. At pH higher than 8, Al(OH)₃ is converted to Al(OH)₄ which suppresses the removal of COD and color and accounts for the lower percentage of COD and color removal at alkaline pH (Reaction no 8 to 10) [46].

Reaction for alkaline and acidic conditions:

For acid condition

$\text{Al}\to {\text{Al}}^{3+}+3{\text{e}}^{-}$ (6)

${\text{Al}}^{3+}+3{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}\to \text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_3+3{\text{H}}^{+}$ (7)

For alkali condition

$\text{Al}\to {\text{Al}}^{3+}+3{\text{e}}^{-}$ (8)

$3{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}+3{\text{e}}^{-}\to \frac{3}{2}{\text{H}}_{2\left(\text{g}\right)}+3{\text{OH}}^{-}$ (9)

$2\text{Al}+6{\text{H}}_{\text{2}}\text{O}+{\text{2OH}}^{-}\to 2\text{Al}{\left(\text{OH}\right)}_4^{-}+3{\text{H}}_2$ (10)

Highest COD and Color removal was observed around pH 7, where the buffering effect during EC also plays a significant role investigated by earlier authors [16] [22] [44] [47]. In this study, initial pH was adjusted at two acidic levels, pH 5 and pH 6 which rose to pH 6.73 and pH 7.28 respectively. In acidic condition, hydrogen ions were liberated at cathode which neutralized the pH of the aqueous solution in EC. This study, it was examined that initial basic pH 8 and 9 reduced to 7.88 and 8.38, respectively due to the buffer reaction. In the basic environment such as at pH 8 and 9, the hydroxide ions precipitate near anode which results in lowering of wastewater pH. The water oxidation and chlorine production at the vicinity of the anode in basic wastewater treatment by EC process also helps in maintaining the pH around 7 [44] [48] [49].

3.3. Effect of Current Density

The effect of current density on the percentage removal of COD and color was studied with an initial COD (584 mg/L) and initial pH 7 of solution (Figure 3). In this study, we observed that COD removal and color removal increased by increasing current density 5.04 mA/cm² to 25.20 mA/cm². When current density was varied from 25.20 to 35.28 mA/cm² the COD removal remained constant at around 58%. However, the percentage of color removal showed positive relationship even after 25.20 mA/cm² current density. Percentage of color removal was approximately% at 25.20 mA/cm² and minor reduction found to be up to 92% at 35.28 mA/cm² current density [49]. In the EC process the higher current density directly proportion to the formation of high coagulant and bubble which causes the high efficiency of the process. Additionally, when gas bubble density increases consequently the size of bubble reduce and enhance the upward floatation of bubble subsequent pollutant reduction and sludge settling increases [48] [50].

3.4. Effect of Time on Treatment

The effect of treatment durations (10 to 50 min) on the percentage removal of COD and color with initial pH (7), current density (25.20 mA/cm²) and electrolyte dosage (0.5 g/L) and resultant finding are graphically presented in Figure 4. Initially, in the experiment the color gradually turns cloudy which may be due to production of Al ions at anode. At the end of the first set of experiment i.e. after 10 min, there was a significant percentage removal of color (Figure 4). The color removal after 20 min of process time is observed to be about 90% and the highest percent of color removal was noted on 40 min of experiment duration. However, no significant change in color removal was observed from 40 min to 50 min time interval (Figure 4). With the progression of time the Al ions which were produced initially and imparted cloudy color at the anode were removed by coagulation method in the form of sludge [46]. The percentage of COD removal has

progressively increased from 10 min to 40 min (Figure 4). After 40 minutes of time duration, no effect on COD removal percentage was observed (Figure 4). COD removal was 58% on 10 min and it reached to 68% in just next 30 minutes which can be attributed to the fact that, Al(OH)_3(S) dissolved in solution and formed hydroxo complexes [Al(OH)m]ⁿ⁻³ [51]. These hydroxyl ions neutralize the pollutants which favor the aggregation and settling of suspended particle and dissolved organic matter resultant higher COD and color reduction [30]. The trend of COD shows no significant removal after 40 min. Therefore 40 min of reaction time was considered as optimum and was used for further study. It is supported by earlier findings [43] [46] [52] [53].

3.5. Effect of the Supporting Electrolytes

Electrolytes are generally used and mixed in the aqueous solutions to enhance its conductivity [54]. In this study we have investigated the effect of two electrolytes (Na₂SO₄ and NaCl) on percentage of COD and color removal. The time duration of experiment, pH and current density was optimized initially as 40 min, 7 and 25.20 mA/cm², respectively. It was observed that COD removal percentage increased as we increased the electrolyte (in both: NaCl and Na₂SO₄) dose from 0.5 g/L to 1.0 g/L (Figure 5). Electrolyte application at the rate of 1.0 g/L for NaCl and Na₂SO₄ results in approximately 70% and 71% COD removal respectively (Figure 5). The increase in COD removal percentage on the application of electrolytes is due to rapid motion of ions in the solution. However, on enhancing electrolyte dose from 1.0 g/L to 2.0 g/L no significant change in COD removal was observed (Figure 5) [50]. On the other hand, on decreasing the value of electrolyte to 0.5 g/L of NaCl and Na₂SO₄ about 98.5% and 98% of color removal was found and no significant change was achieved on the addition of extra amount of electrolyte (Figure 5). On addition of NaCl as an electrolyte in aqueous solution, it converted into ions of chloride (Cl⁻ and OCl⁻) at anode [55].

This chloride plays a crucial role in oxidation reaction which results in degradation of organic matter [56]. Some researchers [44] [57] [58] have reported that Cl⁻ ions may react with lignin and phenols present in pulp and paper industry effluent and produce oxidizable chlorolignin and chloro-compounds. After discharging these chlorolignin & chlorocompounds in the freshwater ecosystem they cause harmful effects on the fauna and flora [17]. To the best of our knowledge, there is no harmful chemistry is associated with the use of Na₂SO₄ therefore; Na₂SO₄ may be a good possible option instead of NaCl as an electrolyte. Nevertheless, this observation requires to be proven by experimental evidence and thus this constitutes the future analysis in this direction.

3.6. Biodegradability Study

Biodegradability of the effluent (BOD/COD) has been measured at optimum conditions. During the treatment the biodegradability of effluent increased progressively and reached maximum at around 40 min by electro-coagulation. After 40 min of treatment there is no improvement in the biodegradability index. Therefore, 40 min was assumed to be the optimum time duration for the biodegradability of effluent. In present study it was observed that the biodegradability increased up to 0.41 within 40 min of electrocoagulation process. As reported by previous author, the sample of wastewater considered ease to biodegradation when the value BOD/COD ratio reaches in the range of (0.4 - 0.8) and the treatment process mentioned as effective for the destruction of pollutants [55] [59].

3.7. Reuse Option for EC Treated Water

According to Table 3, all residual operating parameters were in the prescribed range of the World Health Organization (WHO) and CPCB standard that ensure the reusability of treated water for irrigation purposes. This EC process and its applications are environmentally sustainable and economically viable.

4. Sludge Characteristics and Its Management

Characterization of sludge involves the explanation of sludge behavior during the treatment and disposal but improper dumping of EC sludge may contribute main consequences such as leachate, odour, transportation, escalating cost and

*PL = Permissible Limit.

negative effect on the environment [61]. As for environmental consideration only, sludge disposal is not necessary but a need of sustainable sludge management is the necessity. So, analysis of the sludge and an integrative approach practice became a necessity to understand its properties and management. In this study main focus on the characterization which provides the valuable information to alternative approaches for reusing it in agriculture land applications. The major physiochemical characteristics are given in Table 4. The sludge produced in EC process found to be dark brown in color and average moisture content was 15%, less moisture content will be helpful in reduced weight and handling properties of sludge. The pH was found to be basic in nature 7.90 this may be due to the basic nature of paper mill effluent and buffering effect of EC process. This could be beneficial for agriculture soil which has low pH value somewhere in Indian subcontinent. The higher organic content in sludge is working as a soil conditioner and enhances the soil fertility [62]. The volume of sludge in g/L was measured on dry basis formed by 1 L of wastewater during the treatment at optimum condition followed by separation and drying process. It was found to be 1.07 g/L. The quantity of sludge development is not act of anode ingestion whereas the maximum amount of sludge is formed at the neutral pH

Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscope-Energy Dispersive Spectroscopy (FESEM-EDX) Analysis of Sludge

The sludge and scum both were analyzed by scanning electron micrographs (SEM) to identify its morphological characteristics. As clearly shown in Figure 6(a) and Figure 7(a), the scum particles look like more even and porous in comparison to the sludge particles, which is due to floatation process which occurred during EC. On the other hand, sludge particles seem dense, which are suitable for the settling process. The variation of particle size in both sludge and scum varied 2 - 24 and 2 - 19 µm respectively in Figure 6(b) & Figure 7(b) and found to be mostly amorphous in nature. In case of scum which particle seems big size, these may be due to aggregation of several particles otherwise all particle found to be less than 20 µm.

The EDAX analysis was performed for the confirmation of elemental constituent in sludge scum. Figure 8(a) indicates that the aluminum (43.24%) and oxygen (42.35%) content are in considerable amount followed by Manganese, chlorine, calcium, sulfur, carbon, sodium, silicon and phosphorus, all of which

were in the range of (1% - 3%) and rest were present in less than 1%. On the other hand, Figure 8(b) represent the scum, in which top content was oxygen (41.42%) and aluminum (23.51%) followed by calcium, sulfur, chlorine, sodium, manganese, magnesium nitrogen, zinc and silicon were present in the range of (1% - 4%) and leaving behind all other elements were less than 1%. As aluminum content was seen to be present in good quantity in both sludge and scum, it can be recovered and applied for the removal of pollutants from wastewater [63]. Most of the essential elements mentioned as nutrients for the growth of plants are present in good amount in both sludge and scum. So, it is suitable to be used as blending material for compost process [32]. Nevertheless, further experimentation is needed for the composting process.

5. Conclusion

The encouraging results achieved from experiments show that the electrocoagulation is a promising process and has the potential to reduce the BOD, COD, Color, TOC and TDS from pulp and paper industry wastewater. The overall reduction in COD, Color, TOC and TDS was 70%, 98%, 68% and 41% respectively; biodegradability ratio enhanced up to 0.41 at pH = 7.00, current density = 25.20, time = 40 min and a dose of electrolyte 1 g/L with 100 rpm stirring speed. The analysis was repeated in triplicate and result showed the good repeatability in the error range of 2% - 5%. SEM-EDX analysis revealed that EC sludge can act as a potential nutrient for plants growth and can be used for several other purposes. All the physiochemical parameters of EC treated water were found below the permissible limit prescribed by WHO and CPCB; thus, can be used as an alternative to reduce the freshwater input in agriculture fields.

Acknowledgements

The research grant for this study provided by the University Grant Commission, New Delhi, Government of India, is gratefully acknowledged

Conflicts of Interest

The authors declare no conflicts of interest regarding the publication of this paper.

Cite this paper

Kumar, D., Gaurav, V.K. and Sharma, C. (2018) Ecofriendly Remediation of Pulp and Paper Industry Wastewater by Electrocoagulation and Its Application in Agriculture. American Journal of Plant Sciences, 9, 2462-2479. https://doi.org/10.4236/ajps.2018.912178

References